google sheets & premium reports:
Assessing Dividend Coverage for BDCs:
The following are the three categories of methods that I use for comparing dividend coverage:
- Historical dividend coverage: using adjusted earnings (excludes certain one-time expenses) taking into account recurring vs. one-time revenues, cash vs. PIK interest income, etc.
- Projected dividend coverage: using best, base and worst case scenarios taking into account potential credit issues, portfolio growth/decline, changes to portfolio yield, various amounts of non-recurring income from dividends and fees, changes to borrowing and operational expenses.
- Optimal Leverage Analysis: assessing future dividend coverage based on portfolio growth using available cash and borrowings (leverage) as well as changes in portfolio yield, apples-to-apples comparison of BDC dividend coverage using similar amounts of leverage.
Historical Dividend Coverage
Most investors rely on historical dividend coverage for assessing potential dividend coverage. However, when it comes to weighting the previously mentioned three categories of dividend coverage, historical is typically the least reliable indicator for future coverage. There are many reasons for this including constantly changing income and expense trends as well as portfolio credit issues. Many of the BDCs that have recently cut dividends, announced that the primary drivers of the reduced distributions were related to potentially lower yields on investments either due to yield compression, rotating into safer investments and/or recent portfolio credit issues. Most of these BDCs had “spillover” or excess distributable income and gains that could have been used to cover shortfalls, but management decided to align the dividends with projected earnings.
Projected Dividend Coverage
Projecting dividend coverage is mostly about reading the trends for income and expenses. This includes general sector and specific company trends, watching for portfolio credit issues, changes to capital structure and borrowing costs as well as estimating a range of performance for portfolio growth and non-recurring income.
Optimal Leverage Analysis
This is a longer term run rate analysis of dividend coverage that takes into account the potential for portfolio growth with available capital (excluding equity offerings). I use stable and lower portfolio yields with minimal amounts of non-recurring income to project dividend coverage with a fully ramped portfolio using “optimal leverage”. For an example of this analysis, please see the table below from my article, “Upcoming Dividend Cuts For BDCs: Part 1“, that correctly predicted a previous dividend cut for MCC. Ultimately, MCC reduced its quarterly dividend from $0.30 to $0.22 which was exactly the projected earnings during a “worst case scenario” of reduced portfolio yield and lower amounts of non-recurring income as shown in the table below. My pricing for MCC anticipated this quarterly dividend reduction to $0.22 well before it was announced.